L’italiana in Algeri at Blackwater Valley Opera Festival – Review

Extract from review published June 4th on Bachtrack.com.

With all the laudable efforts to detach from opera the label of an elitist art form, there is an undeniable pleasure in attending an opera performance in a luxurious setting. The Blackwater Valley Opera Festival leverages exactly the seductive power of this combination. Given such plush context, the risk is that of experiencing an anti-climax. Did it happen with L’italiana in Algeri? Partially. While the average quality of the production was good, there were a few less successful elements that visibly detracted from its full enjoyment… Continue reading on Bachtrack.com.


Verdi Gala by Lyric Opera at the National Concert Hall, Dublin, 16/5/2017 – Review

Verdi Gala by Lyric Opera at the National Concert Hall, Dublin, 16/5/2017 – Review

You would not normally expect to see a venerable nonagenarian former singer and a much younger transgender one together on the stage of the National Concert Hall, but that’s what happened during the Verdi Gala by Lyric Opera on the 16th of May.

The concert was an early celebration of the 90th birthday of Dr. Veronica Dunne, or Ronnie, as she’s more affectionately known. Dunne – a patron of the opera company itself – has been a leading light in Irish opera for decades.

She came on stage towards the end of the concert to receive flowers and an affectionate address by artistic director Vivian J. Coates, after which followed a choral “Happy

Verdi Gala2
Veronica Dunne and Vivian Coates.

birthday” from the standing audience and the singers on stage, including Lucia Lucas, a prominent American transgender baritone currently making her name in Europe.

The concert program was, to a degree, surprising and unconventional. It didn’t dig into the most blood stirring Verdi repertoire and instead invited the audience to savour some lesser known arias, together with more than a few orchestral pieces.

For example, from Nabucco we heard the Overture instead of the famous chorus with the same melody (“Va’ pensiero”), while from Il Trovatore the playful “Coro di Zingari” was chosen over the heart rending aria “Di quella pira”.

It was almost an exercise in self-constraint, as if the program didn’t want to dilute and short-sell the most powerful Verdi pieces. This choice certainly served to highlight both the excellent execution by the Lyric Opera Orchestra (directed by John Rigby) and the musical genius that Verdi was.

The singers all brought their own particular talents to the evening. Soprano Sinead Campbell Wallace impressed with her technical skill, especially in “Pace, pace, mio Dio” (La forza del destino), as well as for her beauty.

Tenor Marc Heller showed off his extremely pleasing, round and warm voice. Baritone Lucia Lucas confirmed – as in her performance in Madama Butterfly last February on the same stage – her ability to passionately dive into a role.

Her first entrance on stage may have left some surprised, with the baritone wearing a masculine tuxedo paired with a lacy top and high heels. But at the end of “Credo in un Dio crudel” (Otello), the audience celebrated her voice and interpretation with a big applause. Her execution of the aria was in fact one of the evening’s highlights, together with Macbeth’s chorus of witches and duet “Parigi o cara” from La Traviata.

But there was one out of tune note in the evening: this show was worthy of a Saturday night, which would have allowed a larger and more varied audience to fill the theatre, while the choice of a Tuesday was possibly due to financial constraints. If Verdi is not synonymous with opera tout court, he is certainly synonymous with what people most commonly associate with and love in opera: high pathos, unforgettable arias and music, archetypal human tragedies.

Hard as it is to believe, Lyric Opera, who do commendable work to deliver to Irish audiences staples of the classic operatic repertoire, do not receive any public funding. The responsibility to preserve and spread such a rich cultural heritage cannot be left on the shoulders of the Italian Cultural Institute in Dublin, which today is the main contributor to this opera company.

The concert was a great teaser for the upcoming Lyric Opera’s production of Verdi’s matchless work “La Traviata” on the 4th, 5th and 7th of November 2017 at the NCH. Write down those dates on your diary.




Acis and Galatea at the Pavilion Theatre, Dun Laoghaire, 5/4/17 – Review.

Acis and Galatea at the Pavilion Theatre, Dun Laoghaire, 5/4/17 – Review.

Extract of my review for Bachtrack:

Handel – in Dublin at least – is practically synonymous with Messiah, probably also because this is the place where the oratorio was first performed. So you’d be forgiven for not associating immediately his name with opera. No bigger mistake. Not only Handel was mainly an opera composer, but Acis and Galatea is considered by many the highest form of pastoral operaOpera Theatre Company production of the 1718 work was outstanding. The endless joys of Handel’s sublime music were matched by stunning performances both by the Irish Baroque Orchestra conducted by Peter Whelan and by the singers

Acis & Galatea
Fearghal Curtis, Eamonn Mulhall (Acis) & Andrew Gavin in Opera Theatre Company’s production of Handel’s Acis & Galatea. Photo by Ros Kavanagh.