The Arts Council has announced a 49% increase in opera funding for 2018 and an open call to (re)establish a national opera company.

This is quite ironic, but for the best. Only last week we were lamenting on this blog the lack of funding and of an appropriate policy for opera in Ireland and, right after (on the 17th of February), we found out that the Arts Council announced some major initiatives in this sector. So much for the power of wishing!

The big news is that the Arts Council has issued an ‘open call’ for proposals for a “regular provider of an annual season of Irish-produced, main-scale, predominantly core-repertoire opera in Dublin from an agreed date in 2018”. Yes, that means we will see more Traviata and Tosca in Dublin. This “provider” would basically take the place of what Opera Ireland was until 2011, filling a six year gap in the existence of a national opera company. This will be possible thanks to a significant 49% increase in opera funding: the budget for opera will in fact go from 3.26 M in 2016 to 4.85 M in 2018.

Among the other initiatives that will be covered by this increase in opera funding, we find the following: a “new opera” commissions award to fund, in advance, new works by Irish composers and librettists; the restoration of bursaries for individual opera artists for amounts of up to €10.000; a significant increase in 2017 of the Council’s “Travel and Training” fund to allow Irish artists to undertake specialised training abroad. There will also be a continued support from the Council to festival opera and small-scale touring opera.

This is all welcome news and will sound like music (forgive the pun!) to the ears of both opera producers and opera lovers. Next step, the planning and construction of a dedicated opera house in Dublin ;-).



“Madama Butterfly” at the National Concert Hall Dublin (18/2/17) review.

“Madama Butterfly” at the National Concert Hall Dublin (18/2/17) review.


Of all the tragic operas, Madama Butterfly is perhaps the most universally heart-rending. This is not only because the core of the story is so common (a young woman seduced and abandoned by a cynical men), but also because of its chronological vicinity to us: of all the ‘classic’ repertoire, this opera is only little more than a century old and, for all the exoticism of the Japanese setting and costumes, it feels very modern.

Madama Butterfly, like Bohème and Tosca but possibly even more, beautifully conveys in music the enchantment of being in love and for two and a half hours casts an intoxicating spell on the audience. But, in order for this spell to happen, you need the magic potion that makes opera: the right voices with the right interpretation, the latter being particularly important in this work.

Lyric Opera’s production was one of high standard. The set design was very simple and not changing between the three acts, more a hint to the Japanese location, but the direction and the singing were overall so strong that made you forget the lack of any special effect. By contrast the costumes were quite lavish and more than compensated for this. Ultimately, such simplicity of staging only reminds us of the essence of opera, which is the voice. The orchestra and chorus, respectively under conductor John Rigby and chorus director Richard McGrath did a very fine job.

Korean soprano Hye-Youn Lee performance in the title role was simply outstanding, both from a vocal and from an acting point of view, displaying great psychological finesse and a beautiful voice. She was an utterly credible Madama Butterfly and you could sense her previous experience in the role. She also smartly escaped the risk, almost intrinsic to the role, of appearing too histrionic. Surprisingly, the aria Un bel dì vedremo felt a bit rushed, not completely in tune with the actual words of the aria which is, instead, all about “the long wait”, the anticipation of Pinkerton’s arrival and the emotional turmoil, the impatience of seeing again the long gone husband and the artificial hiding, partly a ‘game’ (“un po’ per celia”) and partly a defense against the strong emotion (“e un po’ per non morir”); I could not feel all this complexity and internal battle in the singing, nor the sudden shift of mood in the aria was vocally well underlined. Although this is the most famous aria in the opera, Hye-Youn Lee performance was, for the rest, so exceptionally good that this glitch did not spoil the magic she was absolutely able to create on stage from start to finish.

Julian Hubbard has a fine tenor voice which, although not quite matching in weight that of Hye-Youn Lee, sustained Pinkerton’s role really well throughout the evening. More chances to play the unfaithful American husband will no doubt grant him a higher level of identification with the part, which could possibly do with slightly less emphatic gestures, together with a higher dose of passion in the aria “Bimba dagli occhi pieni di malia”. Mezzo-soprano Sarah Richmond was a nice Suzuki, significantly contributing to the dramatic success of the poignant duet with Madama Butterfly at the start of the second act. Again here, less would have been more in terms of gestures to convey sorrow, while from a vocal point of view the audience might have perceived the lower notes as too rarified.

Lucia Lucas (as Sharpless) was absolutely impressive, arguably one of the most powerful and beautiful baritone voices you could hear. Her acting ability was equally good, and after listening to her you are just left with the eagerness of hearing her in bigger roles with juicy arias, roles that will give her the chance that she highly deserves to shine. Her voice will probably be best used in Verdi’s grave baritone roles, and in that regard the upcoming Verdi Gala at the National Concert Hall on May 16 should prove unmissable just for her presence.

Among the minor roles, that of David Howes’ Prince Yamadori stood out, and it would be interesting to hear him again in new productions.



Young Irish mezzo Tara Erraught to sing at the Met (and of other losses for Ireland).

The Irish mezzo-soprano Tara Erraught has announced last night on Twitter that she got an engagement with the Metropolitan in New York to sing in Les contes d’Hoffmann in the role of

Tara Erraught. Photo by Dario Acosta.

Nicklausse. Anybody who has had the chance to hear her luscious voice will not be too surprised by this
news. Her performance as Rosina last year in Il Barbiere di Siviglia in Dublin for Opera Theatre Company at the Bord Gáis Energy Theatre was a real highlight of the opera scene inIreland.

As much as we are delighted at the news that a local young talent will appear on one of the world’s most famous stages for opera, we can’t help but regret the lack of opportunities in Ireland for the many talented Irish classical singers. Another name that comes to mind is that of Jennifer Davis, the young soprano currently in the Jette Parker Young Artist program at Covent Garden: if you ever heard her singing Un bel dì vedremo you’d know what we mean; she too will be singing at the Met one day (you’ve read it here first!). Each of these singers could fill a theatre in no time.

We truly wish that somebody in the high spheres of politics is listening to the outcry of the many opera lovers in this country. Now that m

Soprano Jennifer Davis. Photo by Brendan Davis.

oney is back in the economy, what’s the excuse for not having a national opera company, like the long standing one that was shamefully shut down in 2011, Opera Ireland? Does Ireland really want to remain the only country in Europe  without a national opera company, and Dublin the only European capital without a dedicated opera house?  Because, as wonderful as Wexford Festival Opera is, a “National Opera House” should be where the people are, and 33% of the Irish population lives in Dublin, not Wexford. If we want culture to be really democratic and not elitist, as opera is often unjustly accused to be, we should bring culture to the people, and that involves physically bringing it to the people: not everyone who loves opera in Dublin can afford the luxury to travel two hours and back (or less staying overnight…) to attend a performance in Wexford. And anyway the problem remains of the shortage of opportunities to hear the ‘classics’ of opera, as repeatedly pointed out by Michael Dervan in the pages of The Irish Times. Ireland needs to make opera available and affordable, and to do so where the majority of Irish people live. Is anybody listening?


Feel free to add your comments below, we’d really love to hear the readers thoughts on this.